Let me start with a couple of quotes from people I admire:
Fr Peter Brocardo SDB, my rector when I was studying in Rome, had a knack of putting things simply and in appealing ways. Talking of obedience, he told us, “The Salesian with the greatest degree of initiative is the most obedient Salesian.”
Is that how you and I understand obedience—as a passion for doing good, an eagerness to reach out and help, a holy restlessness to do as much good as we can? Don’t we often reduce obedience to saying Yes to the superior or following the time-table?
Where on earth did we get pious-sounding phrases like, “The bell is the voice of God”? Did Jesus ever say that? He insisted on deep and genuine love, right to the point of being ready to die for someone else. He never gave us the bell or time-table as the marks of fidelity. Otherwise, a selfish person who likes to have meals on time, and turns up punctually for breakfast, lunch and supper would be the ideal religious!
Another quote—this time from St Benedict, the grand-father of all of us who have chosen organized religious life. Knowing the vow of obedience gave the abbot lots of power, Benedict warned, “If an abbot asks the religious to do what he (superior) wants, rather than what God wants, he will go to hell!”
A strong warning! A religious superior has no right to make the members do whatever he likes and wants. He/she is bound to discern, consult and listen before taking decisions about people and works. Just because XYZ is a religious superior, it does not follow that whatever he/she wants is God’s will for the community.
(Note that the central point of the much talked-about Synodality is to listen, to become a loving, listening, caring family—not an organization that mostly gives orders.)
If people just waited to be told what to do, and did only whatever they were asked to do by religious authorities (Pope, bishops, major superiors), no religious orders would have come into being. Each order is the continuation of the dream and commitment of a man or woman who felt called by God to respond to the needs of his/her time in an new way. This is how Benedict founded his monasteries, or Francis and Dominic started the so-called Mendicant Orders, or Ignatius founded the Jesuit order or Don Bosco started the Salesian Society.
Just waiting to be told what to do is OK for a child. Children do not know what they should eat or wear or learn, or which school to go to, what to do when they fall sick. Adults are in charge.
Religious life is not a parallel to this parent-child relationship. Religious vows can only be made by adults. It cannot be imposed on anyone. If I join religious life without knowing what I am choosing and what I am rejecting, and without inner freedom to make this choice, my profession is not valid.
Fr Joe Mannath SDB
To read the entire article, click Subscribe